Bunni, do you happen to remember the layering and blending modes you used on the image itself? I've been using paper textures for a similar project, and a simple "multiply" doesn't seem to do a very good job of texturing anything but the background.
Fine, don't think I can cut it? I'm gonna start my own paper, with blackjack and hookers! I'll get to the core of this story no matter how boring it might be and show you that I'm no miner punster! I AM GOING TO ROCK THE FOUNDATION OF THIS INDUSTRY! I SHALE SHOW NO MERCY!